MUSCULOSKELETAL RADIOLOGY / ORIGINAL PAPER
Diagnostic accuracy of plain films in detection of thoracolumbar fractures in minor trauma patients: comparison with CT
More details
Hide details
1
1st Department of Clinical Radiology, Medical University of Warsaw, Poland
2
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology of the Locomotor System, Medical University of Warsaw, Poland
Submission date: 2025-04-01
Final revision date: 2025-04-20
Acceptance date: 2025-04-20
Publication date: 2025-05-27
Corresponding author
Marlena Bereźniak
1st Department of Clinical Radiology, Medical University of Warsaw, Poland
Pol J Radiol, 2025; 90: 260-266
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Purpose:
To evaluate the diagnostic value of X-ray in detecting acute thoracolumbar (TL) fractures in minor trauma patients, using computed tomography (CT) as the reference standard, and to assess the impact of rigid spine conditions and reader experience on performance.
Material and methods:
This retrospective single-centre study included patients with acute TL fractures from minor trauma between July 2014 and December 2020, who underwent both X-ray and CT. On CT, the presence or absence of rigid spine conditions, location, and fracture morphology were assessed. Two independent readers (a radiology resident and an attending radiologist) evaluated the radiographs, blinded to CTs. Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were calculated, and interobserver agreement was assessed using Cohen’s κ coefficient.
Results:
Sixty-three patients (32 with rigid spines, 31 without) with 84 fractures were included. The resident radiologist showed lower diagnostic accuracy than the attending radiologist, with more false positives in the rigid-spine group. In both groups, unrecognised fractures were more common for the resident radiologist (61.2% in rigid-spine patients and 48.6% in non-rigid-spine patients) compared to the attending radiologist (51.0% and 40.0%, respectively). Thoracic fractures were more frequently missed than lumbar fractures. Interobserver agreement was moderate (κ = 0.44) in the rigid-spine group and substantial (κ = 0.67) in the non-rigid-spine group.
Conclusions:
Radiographs cannot reliably exclude unstable TL fractures in minor trauma patients. Attention should be paid to the lower thoracic region when evaluating lumbar radiographs.
REFERENCES (32)
1.
Katsuura Y, Osborn JM, Cason GW. The epidemiology of thoracolumbar trauma: a meta-analysis. J Orthop 2016; 13: 383-388.
2.
Zileli M, Sharif S, Fornari M. Incidence and epidemiology of thoracolumbar spine fractures: WFNS Spine Committee Recommendations. Neurospine 2021; 18: 704-712.
3.
Inaba K, DuBose JJ, Barmparas G, Barbarino R, Reddy S, Talving P, et al. Clinical examination is insufficient to rule out thoracolumbar spine injuries. J Trauma 2011; 70: 174-179.
4.
Cason B, Rostas J, Simmons J, Frotan MA, Brevard SB, Gonzalez RP. Thoracolumbar spine clearance: Clinical examination for patients with distracting injuries. J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2016; 80: 125-130.
5.
National Clinical Guideline Centre (UK). Spinal Injury: Assessment and Initial Management. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE); 2016.
6.
Wendt K, Nau C, Jug M, Pape HC, Kdolsky R, Thomas S, et al. ESTES recommendation on thoracolumbar spine fractures: January 2023. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg 2024; 50: 1261-1275.
7.
Expert Panel on Neurological Imaging and Musculoskeletal Imaging; Beckmann NM, West OC, Nunez D Jr, Kirsch CFE, Aulino JM, Broder JS, et al. ACR Appropriateness Criteria® suspected spine trauma. J Am Coll Radiol 2019; 16 (5S): S264-S285.
8.
Lee GY, Hwang JY, Kim NR, Kang Y, Choi M, Kim J, et al. Primary imaging test for suspected traumatic thoracolumbar spine injury: 2017 Guidelines by the Korean Society of Radiology and National Evidence-Based Healthcare Collaborating Agency. Korean J Radiol 2019; 20: 909-915.
9.
Karul M, Bannas P, Schoennagel BP, Hoffmann A, Wedegaertner U, Adam G, et al. Fractures of the thoracic spine in patients with minor trauma: comparison of diagnostic accuracy and dose of biplane radiography and MDCT. Eur J Radiol 2013; 82: 1273-1277.
10.
Sheridan R, Peralta R, Rhea J, Ptak T, Novelline R. Reformatted visceral protocol helical computed tomographic scanning allows conventional radiographs of the thoracic and lumbar spine to be eliminated in the evaluation of blunt trauma patients. J Trauma 2003; 55: 665-669.
11.
Rhea JT, Sheridan RL, Mullins ME, Novelline RA. Can chest and abdominal trauma CT eliminate the need for plain films of the spine? Experience with 329 multiple trauma patients. Emerg Radiol 2001; 8: 99-104.
12.
Ballock RT, Mackersie R, Abitbol JJ, Cervilla V, Resnick D, Garfin SR. Can burst fractures be predicted from plain radiographs? J Bone Joint Surg Br 1992; 74: 147-150.
13.
Dan Lantsman C, Barkay G, Friedlander A, Barbi M, Stern M, Eshed I. Whole spine CT scan for the detection of acute spinal fractures in diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis patients who sustained low-energy trauma. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2020; 45: 1348-1353.
14.
Westerveld LA, van Bemmel JC, Dhert WJ, Oner FC, Verlaan JJ. Clinical outcome after traumatic spinal fractures in patients with ankylosing spinal disorders compared with control patients. Spine J 2014; 14: 729-740.
15.
Finkelstein JA, Chapman JR, Mirza S. Occult vertebral fractures in ankylosing spondylitis. Spinal Cord 1999; 37: 444-447.
16.
Backhaus M, Citak M, Kälicke T, Sobottke R, Russe O, Meindl R, et al. Spine fractures in patients with ankylosing spondylitis: an analysis of 129 fractures after surgical treatment. Orthopade 2011; 40: 917-920, 922-924 [Article in German].
17.
Schiefer TK, Milligan BD, Bracken CD, Jacob JT, Krauss WE, Pichelmann MA, et al. In-hospital neurologic deterioration following fractures of the ankylosed spine: a single-institution experience. World Neurosurg 2015; 83: 775-783.
18.
Vaccaro AR, Oner C, Kepler CK, Dvorak M, Schnake K, Bellabarba C, et al.; AOSpine Spinal Cord Injury and Trauma Knowledge Forum. AOSpine thoracolumbar spine injury classification system: fracture description, neurological status, and key modifiers. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2013; 38: 2028-2037.
19.
Panda A, Das CJ, Baruah U. Imaging of vertebral fractures. Indian J Endocrinol Metab 2014; 18: 295-303.
20.
Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 1977; 33: 159-174.
21.
Pouw MH, Deunk J, Brink M, Dekker HM, Kool DR, van Vugt AB, et al. Is a pelvic fracture a predictor for thoracolumbar spine fractures after blunt trauma? J Trauma 2009; 67: 1027-1032.
22.
Wintermark M, Mouhsine E, Theumann N, Mordasini P, van Melle G, Leyvraz PF. Thoracolumbar spine fractures in patients who have sustained severe trauma: depiction with multi-detector row CT. Radiology 2003; 227: 681-689.
23.
Berry GE, Adams S, Harris MB, Boles CA, McKernan MG, Collinson F, et al. Are plain radiographs of the spine necessary during evaluation after blunt trauma? Accuracy of screening torso computed tomography in thoracic/lumbar spine fracture diagnosis. J Trauma 2005; 59: 1410-1413.
24.
Hauser CJ, Visvikis G, Hinrichs C, Eber CD, Cho K, Lavery RF, et al. Prospective validation of computed tomographic screening of the thoracolumbar spine in trauma. J Trauma 2003; 55: 228-234.
25.
Patten RM, Gunberg SR, Brandenburger DK. Frequency and importance of transverse process fractures in the lumbar vertebrae at helical abdominal CT in patients with trauma. Radiology 2000; 215: 831-834.
26.
Krueger MA, Green DA, Hoyt D, Garfin SR. Overlooked spine injuries associated with lumbar transverse process fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1996; 327: 191-195.
27.
Qasem KM, Suzuki A, Yamada K, Hoshino M, Tsujio T, Takahashi S, et al. Discriminating imaging findings of acute osteoporotic vertebral fracture: a prospective multicenter cohort study. J Orthop Surg Res 2014; 9: 96. DOI: 10.1186/s13018-014-0096-1.
28.
Strickland CD, DeWitt PE, Jesse MK, Durst MJ, Korf JA. Radiographic assessment of acute vs chronic vertebral compression fractures. Emerg Radiol 2023; 30: 11-18.
29.
Barkay G, Dan Lantsman C, Menachem S, Shtewee A, Ackshota N, Caspi I, et al. Limitations of plain film radiography in identification of hyperextension fractures in patients with ankylosing spinal disorders. Global Spine J 2022; 12: 24-28.
30.
Werner BC, Samartzis D, Shen FH. Spinal fractures in patients with ankylosing spondylitis: etiology, diagnosis, and management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2016; 24: 241-249.
31.
Aso-Escario J, Sebastián C, Aso-Vizán A, Martínez-Quiñones JV, Consolini F, Arregui R. Delay in diagnosis of thoracolumbar fractures. Orthop Rev (Pavia) 2019; 11: 7774. DOI: 10.4081/or.2019. 7774.
32.
Turen CH, Mark JB, Bozman R. Comparative analysis of radiographic interpretation of orthopedic films: is there redundancy? J Trauma 1995; 39: 720-721.